@BanjoBen
Feedback (already!).
First time I’ve picked up the guitar in a few days, lot going on.
So I pick a song I’ve been wanting to learn (hippie grass one, lot of space… wife caught a bird in the guest house due to an open door a couple days ago. Reminded me of the song when she texted a pic to me over here in the big house of her holding it in her hand)…anyway. Once I figured out the rhythm guitar (capo’d 2 and playing out of that D shape (E) so I’d have all those notes at my finger tips with the minor shape right there at my fingertips too… that I know better than any! I said “Ok play what the lead singer is singing”.
It took about 20 mins of me trying…then the light bulb pulped on and within a “flash” I could see it all starting to come together as one (scales, positions, being able to hear every single note blending and shared among all the instruments…and especially thinking to myself "you must listen for singer and harmony parts even if they are not there (singers or even other instruments).
Oh my this is going to be fun. When you suggested this I was like “yuck more extreme discipline for the next few months”. Nope almost instantly.
Thanks Ben. If that suggestion came in a bottle with a $1K price tag I’d gladly pay for the lesson from anyone. This is going to be fun.
I’ve not had a problem working out a solid rhythm within just a few minutes on any new song in years (10 or more?). Over the past few years of scale work and such I’ve trained my ear to listen to the individual notes from a guitar. In doing this I’d lose track of what chord we were in when I started “jamming” some… but could always focus and get it back on within a measure (or so).
I kind of kicked myself around because I know I’ve never fought keeping up with chord progressions in the rhythm section…and I enjoy playing rhythm guitar. But it was missing it my lead lines, I’d get lost. Not now…Listening to the singer’s lines now lets me see (hear) the changes coming just like if I were signing and playing rhythm. When the singers not there I can “sing” it in my head now…all while taking a break and making the chord change.
This stuff is fascinating to me…my life thus far has been lived on the other side of the brain - sports, golf, business, engineering,. etc. There’s an entire world opening up for me to create within…absolutely fascinating in considering how many segments you can split that noggin’ into and just let it do the “conducting” and the part that you control directly is doing the “ah let’s show off a little bit here” or “oh that’s really melodic l’ll reconsider that” , or “Hey I know I could squeeze one of Ben’s licks in here but I am going to pass this time and see what I can come up with”…all the while the brain is keeping everything else right where it’s supposed to be - and it’s leaning hard towards occurring subconsciously.
I type long responses as documentation. At some point over the next millennia someone may very well stumble on this stuff and gain a bit of knowledge and it might help. Sorry if I get long-winded.
for the curious…