Forum - Banjo Ben Clark

Thoughts on Learning Multiple Versions of the Same Song

#1

As I dive back into learning the banjo, I often come across lessons and different versions of songs that I have learned in the past such as Black Berry Blossom. For the most part, the songs will be played similarly, but often there are parts that are quite different from how I have played them in the past. I always watch these lessons and try to pick up something new that can help me improve as a player, but sometimes it’s hard to get into relearning a song that you have played for a while and developed a level of muscle memory.

I’m curious what the thoughts are on this. Would you devote your time to learning a new song or studying a new version of a song you might already know? I know that from an improvisational aspect, knowing different versions of a song is beneficial, and often the licks and techniques do appear in other songs.

#2

Sorry, I should clarify my above post……I’m not talking about learning a Scruggs version, and then learning a Melodic version or single string, but rather learning two or three different melodic versions. If that makes sense.

#3

If nothing else it’s all good study/learning material. I tend to stick with the first arrangement I learned. For example I learned Alan Munde’s Arr of Peaches & Cream. @BanjoBen 's version is slightly different and try as I might I always revert to Alan’s. I tend not to learn multiple arrangements unless it’s in a different Key signature.

1 Like
#4

That’s a good point Archie, I hadn’t thought about versions in different keys. Thanks

#5

I say just examine the differences and put them in your back pocket as options. But the ultimate goal, of course, is not be nailed down to one specific version but rather play from your inspiration of all the things you’ve learned. You’ll get there!

2 Likes
#6

Thanks, that makes sense. It is definitely a long road!:blush:

1 Like