@BanjoBen I am a lefty and started playing as a righty for mandolin. When it comes to strumming, my right hand/wrist is spazzy and has tension whereas my left is controlled and free feeling doing the same movement. Will that smooth out over time or would it be best to switch to lefty?
Lefty or righty
3 Likes
I have known several people that were lefty that chose to play righty and they did fine in time. I am not sure there is an absolute correct answer for you though. How long have you been playing?
3 Likes
As a former right-handed person, I find it much easier to play right-handed than with my left hand. 
I’m not sure how that was supposed to help, but figured I’d throw it out there!
2 Likes
As a natural lefty who plays lefty I can tell you that there are a lot more right handed instruments out there than left handed ones.
4 Likes
All I can say is… Whaaaaaaaaat?!?!?!?! 
2 Likes
Welcome to the forum, @drc! Generally, we’re pretty normal folks around here, but there are some out there that are… well, let’s just say that it takes all kinds to make the world go around!!! Right, @Zachary?!
(Zachary is a friend of mine, so I’m qualified to give him a hard time! 
)
Seriously , though, @drc, we’re glad to have you here!
4 Likes
I don’t have personal experience in this, but my advice is to stay the path with righty instruments. Like @Mike_R says, how long have you been playing?
1 Like
@Searnold I’m a lefty that plays right-handed. I play banjo, not mandolin, but if I can do it, anybody can.
3 Likes
Thank you all for the replies. I apologize for the delay, my dishwasher and washing machine went on the fritz…I’ve been playing banjo and mandolin for about 4 years? I don’t notice it with banjo, just with strumming on mandolin.
1 Like
I can imagine that strumming with your opposite hand would feel weird for sure. I’ve never broken my arm and been forced to use my off-hand for tasks, so I can’t speak from experience of adaptation. All I can say is that I know many lefties that play instruments right handed and they seem to think it’s the way to go.
3 Likes
@Searnold, my grandpa is actually left-handed, and he has showed how hard it can be to be left-handed. He plays a right-handed guitar (because he was never able to find a “good” one as a teenager). He has never tried to use a left-handed one instead. He plays well and comfortable on it, but that’s just his opinion.
Yes, welcome to the forum, @drc!
…Thank you, @CBoling! I’m not normal?!? …never mind, don’t answer that question!!!
A good friend is good at kindly making fun of someone else! You’re a great friend, @CBoling!
I will say, thank you @BanjoBen for having this forum! I have found it very beneficial to my playing and spiritual life and have met a lot of great people to encourage me as well!!! What you do here is so amazing! Thank you!
3 Likes
Yes, thank you so much, @BanjoBen! @Zachary and I actually met through this forum, and he’s become one of my closest friends! I really appreciate all that you do for all of us!
4 Likes
I can if you want me to…
2 Likes