— Begin quote from "Julian"
I don’t care what strings I use, but I know I’ll never use another pair of non-coated strings.
— End quote
I think I’m with you, Julian. I tried the Elxirs, then went back to non-coated strings, and couldn’t believe how much I had become accustomed to the feel of coated strings. I’ve still got a few sets of non-coated strings to go through, but I believe I’m going back to coated strings next time.
I hate that the non-coated strings sound like you’re unzipping a parka every time you move your fingers. 
I’m on the hunt for a good set of coated strings. I think the playability and longevity of the coated strings out-weigh the tiny improvement in tone of the non-coated.
My favorite coated strings so far are the D’Addario EXP’s. they last me a little over a month. that is less than the Elxirs (3 Months) but the coating is much thinner on the exp’s. Uncoated turn dead in about 2 weeks for me but sound the best.
The difference in sound comes from the way they coat them. Elixer coats the string after it is finished being wound, D’Addario coats the bronze before it is wrapped on the core.
elixir: sounds a bit muffled to my ears. get the “fray” after a few weeks of playing. sweet spot last forever. best for practice
EXP’s: no “fray”. sweet spot in sound last much longer than uncoated. much more definition than the elixirs. best for playing out
Uncoated: sweet spot last a couple days. best for recording
Just replaced the EJ17’s on my guitar with Lifespan 7200’s. My fingers are very happy right now, but my ears still haven’t decided.
Hey Larry,
It’s a subjective thing, but my ears have grown to love the sound of the 7200. I used to want to play them in for an hour or two, but now, I even like them right out of the box. Also, weeks later with daily play, they still sound decent. I hope you enjoy them as much as I do.
Definitely liking the 7200’s more since they’ve got a couple of hours on them. They’re kind of bright right out of the package.
I put a set of the 80/20 medium lifespans on the D-18 for the first time yesterday (I think they are MSP6200). They have a very pleasant and usable tone right out of the box. They are darker than the PBs. They sound bassier (I don’t think they are, I just think there is less chime to compete). If I was going to be playing out immediately after a string change, these might be a better choice than the 7200s. I really like the sound to start, but I suspect they will progress through their sweet spot too quickly for my liking. I guess I shouldn’t get ahead of myself. So far, I really like them.
I use D’Addario J74’s on my mandolins and EJ19’s on my guitars. Have tried a lot of different strings over the years but always go back to them. Never cared much for coated strings but to be honest I’ve not tried any in a long time. Think I’ll put a set of those 7200’s on the HD-28 next time I change strings since a few of you guys like them.
Hey Bulldog,
If you like a less bright string, the 6200 lifespan (Med 80/20) are much less bright out of the box. They have a more “natural” sound, but the 7200’s sound great for a real long time once they settle in. I have grown accustomed to the 7200’s and the brightness out of the box doesn’t bother me, but your first time with them they can kind of surprise you.
The old HD is pretty heavy on the bass so I actually prefer a brighter string. Sounds like the 7200’s are what I need. Elderly Instruments (where I order strings anyway) has them on sale for $5.25 so I think I’ll get a few packs. If I don’t like them I guess I could always send you and Larry the other two sets!
$5.25 is a great deal. I recently stocked up on them for about that much with the buy one/get one deal last month (I have about 10 each of lights and mediums). If you don’t like them I am sure you can find some takers.
Finally got around to trying the Lifespan 7200’s. I’ve had them on for a week and they still sound pretty new. Think I’m going to like them, I’ll give 'em another week or two and see. By the way if anybody is in the market for a few sets, Strings and Beyond has a great deal on them at the time of this post and they’ll throw in a Martin guitar wallet which I really like.
Ok, three weeks into the LifeSpan strings now and I’m hooked. My Martin seems to like them better than the D’Addario’s which is unfortunate because of the price difference! Just put a set on my Guild D50 Bluegrass Special. We’ll see how it goes.
Glad you like them. Over the past year, I have had two opportunities to pick them up for about $6, so now I am stocked up at about the price of EJ17s (and they sound good for months). They sound good to me for several times longer than uncoated, so I am actually starting to think of them as a bargain. Until the next “big sale” you can get them at GC for around $11. At Elderly you can by three for $9.50 each:
elderly.com/accessories/names/ma … SP7200.htm
I started out playing on Martin Marquis when I was in high school back in the seventies. I guess I have never bought any other brand of guitar strings to this day. I switched to SP phosphor bronze a while back and have really liked them. I have yet to try Lifespans but I think I will buy some and see how they sound. I had always played lights until I bought my Taylor, which I strung with mediums. They took a toll on my fingers at the beginning, but the sound is really great.
I have tried every string out there and have stacks of packs I don’t use anymore. Tried going back to the cheaper strings recently and after a year or more of using coated Elixer poly webs it hurts…lots of string finger noise and just didn’t enjoy them. Tried the Nano web and they are Crap, but the original Poly webs hold up sound good and last a good while. I use heavy picks and the nano webs wear out in about a day or two. The Martins are ok to, but still prefer the 12/54 Poly Web.
— Begin quote from "Jerry M"
I use heavy picks and the nano webs wear out in about a day or two.
— End quote
Doh! 
Thanks for saving me from trying those out.
I have used both the elixir and the Martins and I have a set of elixirs on the guitar now and to tell you the truth I prefer the Martin XP mediums they last as long and the have a special tone to them that the elixir does not have after about a week they are sort of bland . but from now on I will use Martin strings they have the best sound for me . and they last just as long if not longer than the Elixir strings. I like the color of the B and E string also they are a brass colored string and it just makes the guitar look much more mellow also . Tone is like beauty is to the eye it is to the ear of the beholder . The next set will be Martin meds and I will stay with them . The 56 on top makes for a mean bass and the E string on the bottom is thick enough you can strike very hard and it still sounds great.
I have noticed a big advantage to coated strings is the non coated hurt the fingers of older folks so when I change next time it will be life span lights . the older we get the more we hurt LOL Most of the coated strings I have used I was satisfied with .
I just put a set of D’Addario the EXP’s on my Martin today Aug the 9th 2014 and I have played them for about twenty minutes and like what I hear . the feeling under the fourth string as I slide leaves a tingle on my noting finger but no sound can I hear . I have tried the Elixirs but found I like the Martin better but the last set I bought went dead in about three weeks .so I sent for the D’Addario strings, light gauge and like them . The bottom E string amplifies better with these . I was taken aback when I read on the package this string was red and this one black and so on thinking oh no these are colored strings ., The ends are colored to tell them apart . no big deal LOL . I think these will be keepers and I will use them for awhile .