the link and picture will be below in this link… I hope
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1sGcvQqYKi0FhAR_G4UwHyB1WochRGDGMV6R4m3FKfpc/edit?usp=sharing
@BanjoBen and forum fam, I am learning this song to play at church on a wednesday night and I had a question or two that maybe y’all can help me out with. I want to play it a little slower than conventionally played and i found this video of this dude sing’in. Sounds good, but i noticed my Banjo Ben song didnt sound right. I was proud of myself that I finally know how to transpose stuff and I found it sounds like the key of A in the video. I guess I just want to know if y’all can take a look at my picture here, watch the video and see if i’m doing this right?
Also, as a bonus help, if you look at the Emin part in secction 14, in the video, there is a fancy walk down part you can hear on the guitar that i want to try and emulate on the mandolin. Being a tone deaf noob, i took my best guess at what it sounded like. what do you think? What does it sound like to you? It still sounds a little off with the notes that i chose for the key of A version. any help would be appreciated as i’m still in the shallow waters of ear training and music theory. Also, when transposing the solo, do you think it is better to use the 7th fret and make it a closed position or to make it work using the open position?
trying it open i run in to a little finger gymnastics when hitting the 3/5 strumming part in section 7 in the transposed version because the 5 becomes the open A string and the 3 on the A would become a D note. well, that leads me to use either the fifth frets of the E and A string to get my D and A note, or use the 7th fret on the D string with an open A. both accomplish the same thing but their sound is not as clean with either of those options, which is why I was considering doing the basic solo in the key of A in a closed position instead. But i want to know your thoughts on what decision makes the most sense and why?
thank you all for your help!